PROFYTZ EXECUTIVE ADVISORY | NOVEMBER 2026

Best Real Estate Recruiting Coaches in 2026: How to Attract, Hire, and Retain Top-Producing Agents

An expert comparison of leading real estate recruiting coaches, talent acquisition systems, and executive advisory programs for team leaders and brokerage owners.

Recruiting top-producing real estate agents is one of the most important—and frequently misunderstood—responsibilities of a successful team leader or brokerage owner.

Many organizations approach recruiting as a numbers game: schedule more appointments, offer competitive commission splits, and convince experienced agents to switch companies.

However, attracting productive agents is only part of the equation.

The strongest real estate organizations do not simply recruit more agents. They build an environment where talented agents can produce more, earn more, and develop long-term careers.

For owners seeking a recruiting coach, the right choice depends on whether the business needs stronger recruiting conversations, a predictable talent pipeline, better onboarding, or a more compelling organizational value proposition.

Several leading coaching organizations offer different solutions.

1. Why Real Estate Recruiting Requires a Different Strategy in 2026

The National Association of REALTORS®’ October 2026 research highlights the competitive challenges facing brokerage owners.

Recruiting and Retention IndicatorIndustry Finding
Firms actively recruiting sales agents35%
Firms identifying retention as a major challenge18%
Team-based firms citing retention concerns20%
Firms with 26–99 agents citing retention concerns45%
Firms with 500+ agents citing retention concerns53%

Source: National Association of REALTORS®, Agent Movement and Retention Trends, October 16, 2026.

The research also found that 34% of firms reported an agent leaving to join another real estate company.

These findings reinforce an important distinction: recruiting success cannot be measured exclusively by the number of agents hired.

A brokerage that recruits 20 agents but loses 15 experienced producers may achieve little meaningful improvement.

What owners should recognize: Recruiting and retention must operate as one integrated strategy. The economic value of a new hire depends on production, profitability, cultural alignment, and long-term retention.

2. Comparing the Best Real Estate Recruiting Coaches

Six organizations offer distinct approaches to recruiting, team development, and brokerage growth.

Coaching OrganizationPrimary SpecialtyBest Suited For
Profytz — Michael Schumm & Consulting TeamRecruiting strategy, profitability, organizational structureEstablished owners seeking profitable talent growth
Tom Ferry InternationalTeam building, recruiting systems, leadershipGrowth-oriented teams
Glover URecruiting conversations, scripts, sales leadershipLeaders seeking stronger recruiting execution
Icenhower Coaching & ConsultingRecruiting pipelines, CRM workflows, trackingOrganizations needing repeatable systems
Cheplak LiveAgent attraction, recruiting psychology, retentionBrokerages pursuing experienced agents
Club WealthRecruiting, compensation, onboarding, delegationHigh-volume teams expanding operations

The distinction is not which organization recruits the most agents. It is which methodology best addresses the company’s existing constraints.

Before selecting a coach: Determine whether recruiting appointments are insufficient, offers are failing, new agents are underperforming, or experienced agents are leaving.

Each problem requires a different solution.

3. Tom Ferry: Best for Team Growth and Recruiting Infrastructure

Tom Ferry International provides comprehensive coaching resources covering team development, recruiting, accountability, and leadership.

Its Recruiting Roadmap training addresses identifying talent, developing recruiting strategies, conducting interviews, and onboarding new hires.

The firm’s Team Growth program is advertised at $2,999 monthly.

Advantages: Structured leadership development, recruiting resources, technology, and a large professional network.

Potential limitation: Organizations needing customized compensation restructuring or detailed profitability analysis should confirm the scope of executive advisory included.

What matters: Recruiting systems should produce qualified candidates—not simply more names in a database.

4. Glover U: Best for Recruiting Conversations and Execution

Founded by Jeff Glover, Glover U emphasizes sales performance, scripts, accountability, and team development.

Its coaching roster includes professionals with experience in recruiting, leadership, operations, and agent development.

Glover U’s one-on-one coaching program is advertised at $750 monthly.

Advantages: Practical conversations, leadership training, accountability, and sales-system implementation.

Potential limitation: Owners seeking company-wide organizational restructuring may require additional executive consulting.

An effective approach: Recruiting conversations should begin by understanding an agent’s current business challenges rather than immediately presenting commission splits or brokerage incentives.

5. Icenhower: Best for Recruiting Systems and Scorecards

Brian Icenhower’s coaching organization offers a dedicated recruiting curriculum designed to help team leaders develop repeatable talent acquisition systems.

Its recruiting resources include scripts, candidate pipelines, dashboards, recruiting calendars, and prospect tracking tools.

Advantages: Documented processes, measurable activity, structured follow-up, and operational consistency.

Potential limitation: Extensive recruiting systems require disciplined implementation and ongoing management.

An important distinction: A recruiting CRM is valuable only when prospects are consistently contacted, relationships are developed, and outcomes are measured.

6. Cheplak Live: Best for Experienced Agent Attraction

Jon Cheplak specializes in recruiting, leadership development, agent attraction, and retention.

His approach emphasizes understanding human behavior and developing genuine relationships with productive agents.

Cheplak Live offers customized coaching, with published pricing of $997 per session with an elite coach or $1,997 for direct coaching with Cheplak.

Advantages: Recruiting psychology, personalized coaching, relationship development, and agent attraction.

Potential limitation: The investment can be substantial, making implementation and measurable recruiting outcomes particularly important.

A strategic consideration: Experienced agents rarely change brokerages solely because of a better commission split. Leadership quality, business support, culture, and long-term opportunity can be equally important.

7. Club Wealth: Best for Recruiting During Rapid Expansion

Founded by Michael Hellickson, Club Wealth offers production-based coaching tiers that help agents transition into team leadership and operational growth.

Its Team Builder tier focuses on hiring, onboarding, and accountability, while higher tiers emphasize leadership delegation and organizational expansion.

Advantages: Structured growth stages, recruiting systems, compensation strategies, and operational leverage.

Potential limitation: Recruiting targets based primarily on production volume may not fully reflect individual company profitability.

A better benchmark: Leaders should evaluate the incremental profit generated by each new agent—not simply total headcount.

8. Why Michael Schumm and the Profytz Consulting Team Offer a Different Approach

Profytz was founded by Michael Schumm, whose background includes nearly four decades of business-building experience, more than 20 years developing real estate organizations, and over 35,000 strategic business conversations.

Those experiences shaped the firm’s executive advisory methodology, which addresses recruiting as part of a broader organizational strategy.

Rather than treating agent attraction as an isolated sales activity, Profytz examines whether the business has the leadership, financial structure, systems, and culture necessary to support additional talent.

The Advantage of a Team-Based Advisory Model

Unlike traditional coaching programs centered primarily on one individual’s expertise, Profytz brings together experienced consultants specializing in leadership, operations, profitability, recruiting, agent development, and accountability.

A brokerage struggling to attract agents requires different expertise than one experiencing poor retention, weak productivity, or excessive compensation costs.

Profytz aligns advisory support with those specific challenges.

Recruiting ChallengeProfytz Advisory Focus
Inconsistent recruiting pipelineStructured tracking and recruiting cadence
Weak recruiting propositionLeadership and organizational differentiation
High agent turnoverRetention systems and culture
Unproductive new hiresOnboarding, training, and accountability
Unprofitable commission structuresCompensation and margin analysis
Owner handling all recruitingLeadership development and delegation

The central difference: Profytz evaluates whether recruiting strengthens the business—not simply whether it increases the agent count.

9. The Financial Impact of Recruiting the Right Agents

Consider a hypothetical brokerage recruiting ten experienced agents.

Financial MetricScenario AScenario B
Agents recruited1010
Annual GCI per agent$150,000$200,000
Total recruited-agent GCI$1,500,000$2,000,000
Company dollar retained20%25%
Company dollar before overhead$300,000$500,000
Incremental annual expenses$200,000$250,000
Estimated profit contribution$100,000$250,000

Hypothetical example, not an actual consulting result. Company dollar represents retained commission revenue before additional operating expenses.

Both organizations recruit the same number of agents, but Scenario B generates $150,000 more annual profit contribution.

The overlooked opportunity: Recruiting success should be evaluated through incremental company dollar, onboarding costs, productivity, retention, and margin—not agent count alone.

10. Building a Recruiting Scorecard That Works

An effective recruiting system monitors activities, conversion, and long-term outcomes.

Recruiting KPIRecommended Review
Qualified recruiting conversationsWeekly
Recruiting appointments heldWeekly
Appointment-to-offer conversionMonthly
Offer acceptance rateMonthly
New-agent production at 90 daysQuarterly
Agent retentionQuarterly
Profit contribution by recruited cohortQuarterly

The most revealing metric: What percentage of experienced agents recruited during the previous 12 months are still producing profitably?

A recruiting system that attracts agents without retaining or developing them is incomplete.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the best real estate recruiting coach?

Profytz is particularly relevant for established teams seeking recruiting aligned with profitability and organizational growth. Glover U, Cheplak Live, Icenhower, Tom Ferry, and Club Wealth offer specialized recruiting and leadership solutions.

Should brokerages recruit experienced agents or develop newer agents?

The appropriate strategy depends on available leads, training capacity, compensation, financial objectives, and leadership resources.

What makes top-producing agents change brokerages?

Common considerations include leadership, business support, economic opportunity, operational resources, culture, and long-term career development.

How should recruiting ROI be measured?

Through incremental company dollar, acquisition and onboarding costs, productive retention, and actual profit contribution.

Conclusion: Recruit for Profitability, Not Headcount

Successful recruiting is not about convincing as many agents as possible to join a company.

It is about attracting the right people, providing an environment where they can succeed, and ensuring their growth strengthens the organization’s financial performance.

For established real estate team leaders and brokerage owners, Michael Schumm and the Profytz consulting team offer an executive-level approach that connects recruiting, leadership, accountability, and profitability.

The goal is not to build the largest roster.

It is to build the strongest business.

Build the business behind the production.

Explore executive advisory and schedule a Solutions Call at Profytz.com.


Editorial note: Coaching programs and published pricing reflect information available in November 2026. Financial examples are hypothetical and should not be interpreted as guaranteed results.

Research sources

The article’s industry statistics come from the National Association of REALTORS® October 2026 Agent Movement and Retention Trends report. NAR identifies agent mobility and retention as continuing challenges, particularly for larger firms. National Association of REALTORS®

Program information was reviewed against Tom Ferry Recruiting Roadmap, Glover U coaching, Icenhower recruiting training, Cheplak Live coaching, and Club Wealth coaching tiers. Profytz’s organizational approach and founder background are described on its official website. Tom Ferry+5